Crumpets. An unsuccessful first attempt.

I was introduced to crumpets on my trip to Seattle when I visited The Crumpet Shop.  BF and I completely fell in love with these crumpets, a taste which I would describe as being a cross between an English muffin and pancakes.  The fluffy, chewy English treats can be eaten sweet with some homemade jam or honey.  They can also be eaten savory with something like pesto or eggs.


Since coming back from Seattle, I've been wanting to recreate our crumpet experience. I purchased some crumpet molds . I found a few crumpet recipes, all claiming to be quite easy. Of course once I saw yeast in the ingredient list, I was a bit worried.

I chose a recipe I found on Test with Skewer. She posted two recipes, but I chose the chewy one because that was the texture I was looking for. My first attempt ended up being a complete disaster.  I don't think it is the recipe, but rather my own personal issues with working with yeast. After letting the dough sit, it became very thick and sticky, like bread dough. I think the dough was supposed to be more liquid like pancake batter, but mine wasn't. The sticky dough was really hard to put into my crumpet molds.

Once put in, the dough simply would not cook. Only the bottom of the crumpets cooked, but I couldn't get the middle to cook. I had to slice each in half and cook both sides. They ended up tasty crispy and not at all fluffy and chewy. They were edible, but they tasted more like toasted english muffins rather than crumpets.

I'm not quite sure where I went wrong, I'll have to try this again. Advice anyone?

Crumpets (found on Test with Skewer, who adapted from a recipe by Dead Man Espresso café, published in September 2010 issue of Delicious magazine)


450g plain flour
7g sachet active dry yeast
300 ml milk
250 ml hot water
Melted butter (unsalted) for greasing

1. Combine the flour and yeast in a large bowl. Mix the milk and hot water together. Make sure it’s not too hot or it can kill the yeast.

2. Make a well in the centre of the flour and pour in  the milk mixture, while mixing all the time. Mix until well combined. 

3. Cover the batter and leave in a warm place for an hour or until doubled in size.

4. Heat a frying pan (preferably non-stick) over medium heat, then grease the crumpet rings. Place the rings in the pan to heat gently, then very carefully, without deflating the batter, pop about 2 tablespoons in each egg-ring. Fry very gently until the top is set (about 6-7 minutes), then turn over and cook the other side. Make sure the top is set or it will get very messy, and try to keep the egg rings on when turning, it helps the crumpet keep its shape.

11 comments on “Crumpets. An unsuccessful first attempt.”

  1. I wiould try the recipe from King Arthur Flour’s website. They are usually easy to follow and pretty reliable. That’s where I first learned yeast baking this last year. You can also call their “Baker’s Hot Line” and they will try to figure out what went wrong. They are a wonderful company.

  2. Hey Kirbie! Just a few things that might come to mind other than what you already said about not having enough liquid. Did the batter rise and bubbly? If not, then I suspect it was the yeast. Maybe the yeast was a little old, temp of the liquids too hot or not hot enough, area where the dough was resting was too cold? The wetter the batter the more bubbly it’ll get, usually.
    I’ve never maked crumpets before I’ve been meaning to try is this one by Foppish Baker:
    A bit more ingredients than the recipe you tried but it sounds like the type of crumpets you and I enjoy. Dang, now I want to make some crumpets.

  3. I suggest you just buy them at the supermarket!

  4. Thanks. I’ll try that recipe next time!

  5. Hi Carol, my batter did bubble, but it also turned my batter into dough, instead of staying liquid. The Foppish Baker does look like the right type of crumpets. I’ll have to try out a few more recipes.

  6. Unfortunately, they aren’t available at any supermarkets near me.

  7. These all information which you can share over here is really very fantastic. Did the batter rise and bubbly? If not, then I suspect it was the yeast. Maybe the yeast was a little old, temp of the liquids too hot or not hot enough.

  8. I made crumpets ages ago (used to eat them all the rime back home in New Zealand but can’t get them here in Austria and had a craving) but I think the batter was pretty thick and they worked out ok…You’ve inspired me to try again!

  9. If you find a good recipe, please let me know!

  10. Pingback: Home

  11. Pingback: Crumpets. An unsuccessful first attempt. | Online REL

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *