Kirbie's Cravings

Fast Food Fish Sandwiches Round-Up and a Giveaway

Wednesday marked the start of Lent and today is the first of seafood/fish Fridays.

If you’ve been a long-time reader of my blog, you might recall that Mr. K observes Lent, and in an act of solidarity, I follow along. For the meat-loving Mr. K, even one day of no meat is torture. I eat fish on a pretty regular basis so I actually find it fun to try out all the different fish options offered by various fast food and fast casual eateries during this time of year.

I thought I’d do a series of posts for the next few Friday rounding up my findings. This week I tackle the fast food chain fish sandwich/burgers. I’m also doing a Giveaway (at the end of this post) for some gift cards to Veggie Grill, restaurant chain on the west coast with a menu of “meat” dishes that are all vegetarian. Perfect for Lent!

Arby’s Reel Big Fillet ($2.99 regular price; 2 for $5 current daily special)

Arby’s is offering one of the cheapest fish sandwich options and staying true to its name– one of the biggest. The irregular fried fish filet is noticeable larger than most of its competitors. I was trying to figure out what the shape was supposed to be. Mr. K thought it was a whale. But once I removed the top bun, it’s actually just a big triangle.

Unfortunately, while it was the cheapest, it was also my least favorite. The fish and batter both tasted pretty bland. The fillet is made with pollock. It’s served with some tartar sauce and iceberg lettuce.

Wendy’s Premium Fish Fillet Sandwich ($3.49)

Wendy’s offering is a little more expensive, but they also use cod fillet. According to Wendy’s website, the cod fish fillets are hand-cut and breaded with panko crumbs.

The cod fillet was thick and the breading produced a satisfying crunch. It was also flavorful and one of my favorites.

I do wish that they used something other than iceberg lettuce, especially since it’s advertised as a premium sandwich. Not only am I not a fan of iceberg lettuce, but the large piece just stuck out awkwardly. I also would prefer that they used a bun that could withstand a little more pressure. It held up fine when eating it, but the appearance isn’t as appetizing with noticeable indents where its been handled.

McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish (various local deals; $4.10 regular price)

I was shocked to learn that the regular price of the McDonald’s version at my local McDonald’s is a whopping $4.10, much higher than even the premium offerings at other chains. While I’ve always had a soft spot for McDonald’s version because I ate it as a kid, the regular price is just ridiculous.

I have to admit though, the filet-o-fish definitely sets the standard in terms of appearance, with it’s perfectly square fillet and its pristine, employee-handle-proof bun. The fish isn’t the best quality- it reminds me of the fish sticks I ate as a kid, but it is tasty and it has the nostalgic factor. It has just the right balance of tartar sauce, melted cheese, and a bouncy bun. The shiny bun is my favorite part. It tastes just like any regular fluffy bread bun but manages to have remarkable resistance to any man-handling pressure. I lightly pressed into it a few times and it left no visible indents.

Two other fish burgers I didn’t yet try this year but tried last year are the Burger King and Carl’s Jr offerings. Burger King is offering theirs for 2 for $5. I wasn’t really impressed with the one I bought last year. I did enjoy Carl’s Jr.’s version and it’s the only one that is charbroiled rather than fried. You can read my post from last year here.

So that’s my fish burger fast food round-up. Did I miss anything other than Jack In the Box, which I just realized while writing this post? I plan on tackling tacos, sandwich shop fish sandwiches and some other miscellaneous options in upcoming weeks.

Now onto the Giveaway. Since it is Lent, Veggie Grill gave me some gift cards to give away to my readers. There will be 2 winners. Each winner will receive two free entree gift cards for Veggie Grill. Please note that the giveaway is being handled through PromoSimple, therefore all comment entries must be entered through the PromoSimple box. The comment prompt is in the PromoSimple box along with bonus entries. Good luck!

14 comments on “Fast Food Fish Sandwiches Round-Up and a Giveaway”

  1. I also have a soft spot for McDonalds’ Filet-O-Fish, but wow – that’s expensive! McD had been doing Filet-O-Fish Fridays where the fish sandwich is much cheaper during Lent, but maybe that varies from store to store.

    • I think it varies from store to store and yes I believe most of them probably have a special on friday. I went on a non-Friday and paid the full price without realizing how high it was until after. yikes!

  2. McD fish filet has always been special to me and sis too. BUT, I cannot believe it’s $4.10 reg price. That’s insane. Do they still have their Fish Filet Friday (I think it’s like $2)?

    Sis sent me link to Chick-fil-A. They now have a fish sandwich that she says looks pretty good.

    • Yes I think they have a deal on Fridays. I went on a Sunday. I wish they had the deal everyday, like most other chains, it’s just the entire period of Lent-not just fridays. Oooh, chik-fil-A, I will have to look into that one

  3. I think Rubio’s is also doing specials? Not too sure since I passed by the sign too quickly.

    • I would imagine they will have some sort of special. I plan on checking them out for a fish/seafood taco round-up.

  4. i so agree with you!
    -i hate iceberg lettuce. It shouldnt be on a premium sandwich.
    -i cant believe the MCD price for JUST a fish filet , not the meal. Your price [$4.10] is even higher than here: $3.39 ! Currently the fish filet is on sale BOGO so its 2/$3.39. SF isnt offering that ?
    …I guess no fish bites this year.

    Here Wendy’s cod sandwich is $3.89.

    I havent been to BK and there is no arbys nor carljr here.

    We do have checkers here. Their fish sandwich i 2/$5 also .

    Anyplace that sells a salmon burger ? maybe Elevation Burger ?

    • I dont know of any fast food chains with salmon burgers. I know Burger Lounge has one but I don’t consider them a fast food chain. The McD here do run deals, usually Friday for the fish filet, but I just think the regular price for the other days of the week is extremely high, especially when most of the other chains are doing the same special through the entire period of Lent

  5. Filet of fish used to be my mom’s favorite. I had no idea that it cost $4! WTF…

    Re: fish sandwiches…
    Recently passed by Rally’s in IB. Their crispy fish sandwich (as well as their crispy chicken) is 2 for $3.

    • I think the regular full price varies a little from location to location, but yeah it’s pretty high up there if you don’t get it during their fish friday special or whatever special they run. I haven’t been to rally’s, thanks for the heads’ up!

  6. Great post; I started one and then have been overwhelmed with work, but Easter isn’t until Late in April, so will at least finish it before then. Inside the Santee Walmart, the McDonald’s has FoF Friday all year, as does the Clairmont Mesa location. Jack in the Box also has lower prices on Friday (there is a small sign at the drive thru; I had to ask for it when I walked inside). I eat ‘no meat on Friday’ (the Catholic version) all year.

    • these posts are time-consuming! haha. Each one is taking me quite a while to write. Can’t wait to read yours! I missed out on JIB, I might try to hit it later on since there’s so many weeks left.

  7. No all Wendy’s have the fish. I have been on the look out. The four locations I tried didn’t have them on the menu. Apparently, it really is like fishing! Where did you find yours?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *