Kirbie's Cravings

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream

This week, I spent a very quick 24 hours in Ohio. Most of those hours were already accounted for so I didn’t have much time to explore, but I knew I could manage one quick stop and I was determined to make that stop Jeni’s Ice Cream.

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream is one of the most well known creameries in the country. They are famous for their creamy consistency and wild flavor combinations. For those not in Ohio, they do ship their ice creams across the country and about 700 stores carry Jeni’s ice cream. For those of you in San Diego, I discovered that recently Bristol Farms in La Jolla began carrying certain flavors. There is also a best selling cookbook.

Despite wearing double layers, a thick winter coat, scarf and hat, this San Diego gal was not prepared for Ohio’s chilly weather. Every moment outside felt like being inside a large freezer with constant blasts of tornado-like winds. But that did not stop me from wanting ice cream.

According to the locals, ice cream is very big in Ohio. You can’t walk more than two blocks without finding a premium ice cream shop, which would explain why Ohio is the home of both nationally known Graeter’s and Jeni’s.

I was delighted to find that there was a Jeni’s shop only about a mile from my hotel and was all set on a late night visit after my dinner plans ended. However, during dinner, Jeni’s came into the conversation and the locals highly recommended that our out-of-town group make this unscheduled stop, especially since it was right across the street from the restaurant we were dining at.

Luckily, Jeni’s is open until 11pm. So off we went. We braved the cold for the quick brisk walk across the street, which seemed much longer when walking against the strong chilly winds, and then were engulfed in warmth upon entering. Once inside, there was a dizzying array of flavors to choose from. The employees were patient, letting us sample spoonfuls of whatever flavors we were curious about before finally settling on a flavor or two.

There were a ridiculous amount of flavors I had never heard of or would never had dreamed of like absinthe + meringues, goat cheese with red cherries, banana cajeta, cherry lambic sorbet, savannah buttermint, just to name a few.

A small costs $4.50, which allows you one big scoop or two small half scoops of different flavors.

In the end, this is what I chose:

Small bowl- goat cheese with red cherries and whiskey and pecans

I loved the unique flavor of goat cheese as a sweet ice cream. Goat cheese has such an intense flavor so the acidity of the red cherries helped to balance that out.ย  I’m a sucker for alcohol laced ice creams and really enjoyed the whiskey and pecan mixture too.

banana cajeta and double toasted coconut

My favorite flavor though was probably the banana cajeta. I’ve had banana ice cream before, but their use of fresh bananas was so refreshing. It wasn’t just blended bananas, but you could actually taste the fresh banana chunks in the creamy concoction. It was swirled with caramel sauce, making it even more delectable.

The double toasted coconut was quite good too, especially if you’re a fan of coconut. You could definitely tell that the coconut flakes had been toasted, as they added a nutty flavor to the ice cream.

Jeni’s ice cream lived up to the hype for me. I was so happy with the ice cream and only wish they had a shop in San Diego. I know that some flavors are available for purchase in San Diego and you can also buy them online, but the packed pints just don’t have the same feeling as eating it from fresh made batches at the store.

Prior to our visit, I had already purchased two pints from Bristol Farms and while I had enjoyed the ice cream, I had not loved it. Part of that may also have been the flavors I chose at random. Now after eating it properly at Jeni’s store, I am absolutely in love. Hopefully I’ll get another opportunity to go back. My visit was far too short and the town of Dublin, where I spent most of my 24 hours, seemed like such a cute place to visit.

Jeni’s Ice Cream
multiple locations in Ohio
1 W. Bridge Street
Dublin, OH 43017


Subscribe to receive new post updates via email

donโ€™t miss a thing!

Get new post updates via email:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

12 comments on “Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream”

  1. Wow goats cheese icecream. Nothing like this in England. I don’t think I would have the guts to try it haha

  2. Fun, I love Jeni’s ice creams!!

  3. She’s right! It’s like a new fad around town, different areas of the city are opening up these grocery stores that literally have everything! You can shop for food, order food and sit down and eat it, and some apparently have salon type services! My girlfriend told me just last night about one she went to during her lunch break yesterday and she saw the salon! Crazy! I love grocery shopping, so I tend to spend a couple of hours at those places! ๐Ÿ™‚

    • Ah, that sounds like so much fun! I already love grocery shopping and most of the ones in SD sound nothing like the ones in Ohio. I will definitely have to plan a return.

  4. I live in Columbus! I moved to ohio from SF after getting married. You’re right, they LOVE ice cream here! Glad you got to try Jenni’s! Haven’t been in a while, but now I want to to try the banana and coconut! ๐Ÿ™‚ come back and I will show you around! ๐Ÿ™‚

    • I definitely want to go back! There were so many things I spotted that I wanted to try. I especially want to check out the grocery stores. One person I was talking to, who is originally from SD, told me how massive the grocery stores are in Ohio and how they have sushi bars, etc.

  5. Wow, every flavor combination sounds so good (except for goat cheese)! And an ice cream shop open til 11 pm? Awesome!!!!!

    When I saw ‘Ohio’ as one of the tags, i got excited, but after reading how cool this place was, disappointed that we don’t have something like that here in s.d.

    • I think the fact that it’s open until 11pm everyday just shows how much the locals love their ice cream. You know, normally I don’t like goat cheese, but I enjoyed it in the ice cream.

  6. I wish I had known about Jeni’s when I was in Columbus back in 2005. I have been to Graeters (neighbor from Ohio State raves about them), although it’s more of a traditional ice cream shop in terms of flavors.

    It’s never too cold for ice cream! I’ve been in Washington DC where the temperatures were in the 30s and had ice cream.

    • Ah, that’s too bad. Esp since Columbus is where most of the Jeni’s are. I saw Graeter’s but didn’t have time to try and saw that it was more traditional ice cream and so I was more interested in Jeni’s. Yeah it was in the 20s that night when we ate the ice cream. still so good though! I’ve seen Graeter’s sold at most grocery stores too.