Kirbie's Cravings

Healthier Red Velvet Cookies

photo of a plate of red velvet cookies
Two years ago I made red velvet cake mix cookies. Last year, I made them again but filled with Nutella. This year I wanted to do another version. I couldn’t think of what to do, and then I came up with this.
photo of red velvet cookies on a baking sheet
This recipe is only three ingredients: cake mix, greek yogurt and chocolate chips. It’s healthier than the original recipe, but tastes just as good. And I finally found some of Nestle’s holiday chips, making the cookies look extra festive.
photo of a stack of cookies
I found the holiday chips at Walmart. It’s a mixed bag of red, green and the normal brown chips. I still don’t understand why they discontinued the swirl chips they used to make, but this is better than nothing.
photo of holiday chocolate chips
I always like to have a few boxes of red velvet cake mix in my cupboards during the holidays so I can whip up a quick batch of festive red velvet cookies. It definitely came in handy this past weekend. I attended a holiday potluck and managed to mess up two recipes dishes I had planned to bring. Already running close to an hour late, I quickly made a batch of red velvet cookies and raided our wine cabinet so I wouldn’t show up empty handed.
close-up photo of a stack of cookies
Then the next day, I found the holiday baking chips I had been looking for everywhere. So I made another batch. So easy and so festive! The greek yogurt makes these cookies extra fudgy and healthier than the regular cake mix cookie recipe which uses oil and eggs.

These will be on my list of cookies I’m baking for my holiday cookie tins to friends and family.
healthier red velvet cookies

Healthier Red Velvet Cookies

Servings: 18
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 14 minutes
Total Time: 29 minutes
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
This recipe is only three ingredients: cake mix, Greek yogurt and chocolate chips. It's healthier than regular red velvet cookies, but tastes just as good. I also used some of Nestle's holiday chips, making the cookies look extra festive.


  • 1 box red velvet cake mix I used Duncan Hines
  • 1 cup Greek strained nonfat plain yogurt I used Fage
  • 1 cup semisweet chocolate chips or Nestle Holiday baking chips


  • Preheat oven to 350°F. Line two baking sheets with silpat mats or parchment paper. Pour cake mix and yogurt into a large glass mixing bowl and stir with a spoon. It may appear that there is too much dry batter to blend with the yogurt but if you continue to stir, it will come together into one uniform dough, little by little. A little more cake mix will stick to the yogurt with each stir. You will likely find pockets of flour each time you stir. Stir and mix until all those pockets of flour are gone. Alternatively, you can probably do this in a stand mixer.
  • Stir in chocolate chips. Take 2 tablespoons of dough and place on cookie sheet, about 2 inches apart. Dough will be sticky to work with. Shape dough into a ball and press down gently on dough as it does not spread that much during baking. Bake for approximately 11-14 minutes. If you touch them, they will still be very soft. The cookies will firm up and set after finished cooling. Let cookies cool on the cookie sheet and firm up before removing them from the baking sheets.

The nutrition information provided are only estimates based on an online nutritional calculator. I am not a certified nutritionist. Please consult a professional nutritionist or doctor for accurate information and any dietary restrictions and concerns you may have.

Did you make this recipe?I'd love to see it! Mention @KirbieCravings and tag #kirbiecravings!

Get new post updates via email

9 comments on “Healthier Red Velvet Cookies”

  1. These look great! I just used these holiday chips for chocolate chip cookies this past week as well.

  2. wow, 3 ingredients? looks like this will be the new recipe to try this year! i usually bake something for the secretaries. they’re probably sick of my lemon bars, so this will be a nice and festive change up.

  3. Okay, I tried making the cookies today and wow, does that dough get sticky. i don’t think i mixed the dough as thoroughly as i could have. i got lazy and impatient. Plus, i really hate touching dough and sticky things. i didn’t even bother shaping the cookies by hand after the first five. i ended up using two spoons to shape the dough. the cookies, even when firmed up, are still too soft for my liking, but tc really enjoyed them. i felt like this was a fail for me.

  4. me again – bert liked it. so not a total fail after all. 🙂 the second cookie sheet, i made the drops bigger so they were more puffy and cake like. that tasted much better. i used the nestle holida baking chips (choc/red/green chips).

    • Hi CC. I’m glad it wasn’t a total fail. Sorry to hear you didn’t like them though. Hmm, the cookies shouldn’t actually be that soft. Maybe right after they are baked but they should actually be more firm on the outside and fudgy on the inside.

    • CC, I was thinking about your cookies again. I think they might be too soft if you didn’t mix enough. Even after the dough comes together, there will likely be pockets of cake flour that appear if you move around your mixing spoon, very similar to the pockets that come up when one makes brownie mix. You do have to mix in and get rid of all those pockets of flour to have enough for the cookie batter. For the sticky dough, you can try letting it sit for a little bit before shaping it. Also, perhaps you could try baking them a little longer. The softness might also be because they are a little underbaked. Mine are done at about 12 minutes, but you could try maybe 14 minutes.

  5. thanks for the useful tips kirbie. for the second batch, i did let them bake a tiny bit longer. those looked bigger and puffier and tasted better. the first batch was thin and tasted like it wasn’t done. i had lots of cake flour bits all over the cookies. they still tasted all right, but they were not ‘presentable’ at all. i planned to bring them to a holiday potluck later that evening. we ended up buying a vegetable tray instead.

    i guess i’m not used to the fudgey texture of these cookies. if i made them right, i’m sure it would have been a lot better. the chips made the cookies look festive though!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating